The Rays have officially struck a deal to acquire veteran first baseman Lucas Duda. In return, the Mets have added right-handed relief pitching prospect Drew Smith.
[RELATED: Updated Rays & Mets Depth Charts]
Duda is playing on a $7.25MM salary this year, just over $2.6MM of which remains and all of which will be absorbed by his new team, per Joel Sherman of the New York Post (Twitter link). To create 40-man roster space, the Rays have designated outfielder Shane Peterson for assignment, as Marc Topkin of the Tampa Bay Times first reported (via Twitter).
Duda, 31, has posted compelling offensive numbers this year after an injury-riddled 2016 season. Through 291 plate appearances, he has slashed .246/.347/.532 and delivered 17 home runs, largely matching the output he provided in his excellent 2014 and 2015 campaigns.
Clearly, the slugger has his limitations, beginning with the fact that he only plays first base (where he has graded as an average defender). He strikes out in about a quarter of his trips to the plate and carries a .246 batting average both this year and in his career. And he’s definitely better against right-handed pitching, though Duda has been better than usual against southpaws this year. But the power is obviously legitimate — Duda has knocked 125 career dingers — and he knows how to draw a walk (12.7% BB rate on the year).
Though the Rays have their own breakout offensive performer at first in Logan Morrison, the team has room for another big left-handed bat. With outfielder Colby Rasmus hanging up his spikes mid-way through the year, the Rays could utilize Corey Dickerson in the outfield to allow Duda to step in at DH.
For the Mets, the move helps to alleviate an immediate roster logjam by opening the door for Jay Bruce to play first base. Of course, that’s not likely to last long, as he and others could yet be on the move. New York will ultimately provide top prospect Dominic Smith his first taste of the majors; with the departure of Duda, that could come in short order.
Meanwhile, New York picks up a pitcher who could be a contributor in New York as soon as the present season — though the Mets likely won’t be in a rush to add him to the 40-man roster. Smith, 23, was a third-round pick in the 2015 draft. He made his way to the Rays as the player to be named later in the winter deal that sent Mikie Mahtook to the Tigers.
With a big fastball and quality curve, Smith looks as if he could turn into a steady and affordable MLB relief asset. The MLB.com prospect team ranked him 30th on the Tampa Bay farm, noting that his upside is as a setup arm. Smith threw 28 2/3 innings of 2.20 ERA ball at the High-A level upon landing with the Rays organization and recently ascended to Triple-A after a quick stop at the penultimate level of the minors.
Joel Sherman of the New York Post first reported that a deal had gained momentum (Twitter links) after Marc Carig of Newsday reported earlier that Tampa Bay had shown some interest in Duda. Jeff Passan of Yahoo Sports (via Twitter) had Smith’s inclusion. MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand tweeted that the deal was complete.
Photo courtesy of USA Today Sports Images.
jackullman
so isn’t he just like LoMo
matthew45
also like dickerson and miller. seems like he’d be redundant on the rays roster
padresfan
I’m always glad to see a player hold their own outside of coors
daruba
Brad miller is hitting .200 at DH
jhinde103
Agreed Miller been a let down
jmdjr1966
The Mets just started dealing. The best player on the market dealt so far was Duda.
The Mets will do what the Yankees did last year at this time.
The Mets will also play better this year as the Yankees did last year..
The Mets do need to actually keep Reed and Blevins and bring up the kid they just got from the Rays and let him pitch.
In the meantime.. Deal Granderson and Cabrera and try to make a deal for a veteran started because Matz looks terrible and needs some time at AAA to figure things out. Montero is coming alive but the Mets till need a fifth starter. Flexen and Tyler Pill are not good options and Wheeler and Harvey are a ways away from coming back. They need to play respectable ball.
El Duderino
Thanks!
Your opening statement claims that Duda is better than JD Martinez. After that I realized the rest of what you said wouldn’t be logical so I skipped it.
jmdjr1966
My apologies. You are correct, I forgot about JD Martinez.
I amend my comment to Duda was the next best position player to be dealt so far this July.
sprtsjnkyyak
good that means the Mariners well not be stupid and trade for hom. Go get em Rays, he is yours, i hope.
rycm131
That’s guys a beast! This would make the Rays the team to beat in the AL
Bullet
Hope this is a sarcastic comment.
frankthetank1985
Duda is very underrated. Rays will be happy to get him. He is a professional in the clubhouse and he is a very under appreciated hitter. Mets lineup is always a lot better with him in it. He has pop and a good eye. With a solid group of rays batters around him he should really benefit. Plus, being a dh will help his health a lot more than playing first.
rycm131
Not sarcastic. He’s a professional hitter.
padresfan
Idk about that one
It would make them more complete, but they’re a far cry away from the best
Maybe tied for 2nd in the al east
zclee06
How’s he a beast he’s batting 246
ralstar
How does BA mean anything? 350 OBP, 550 SLG. Keep clinging to BA to make your points. Your (lack of) knowledge is showing.
jleve618
Your false sense of superiority is showing.
thor would look better in red
ralstar
If you’re using BA as a reason to say someone isn’t good, you flat out don’t understand how to value baseball players. Period. My sense of superiority is anything but false
ralstar
And before I get roasted – I obviously don’t think I’m superior. But I do think his view of player evaluation is antiquated and flat out wrong
jdgoat
Oof batting average. He’s having a great year. I think he has something like a 132 ops plus.
rycm131
He’s like 300 lbs and at least six foot. He’s a beast!
rct
Just stop. Duda is a well above average hitter and serviceable/average defensively. His only problem is staying healthy. Rays fans will love this guy.
willi
He’s a Power hitter that’s all, and Strikes out too Much !
Tyler 20
id like to introduce you to his OBP. he is a little more than just a power hitter who strikes out.
chandlere
ALEast maybe
ND1234
Not even close to being the team to beat. Still might not even make the playoffs.
Jacob Greenia
K’s all over the place
LADreamin
Curse of the power hitter, the man is slugging .532!!
padresfan
Would be a good pick up for them
Duda and longo on the corners
docmilo5
LoMo may be the better glove. I haven’t seen many that run down pop flies in foul territory better than LoMo does.
padresfan
Perhaps
When Duda is on he is on
We all seen him play. Logan is a great player too but imagine that possibilities
The_Porcupine
Wouldn’t be a bad addition. Beats anyone else they’d put out at 1b/DH. Typical Rays move though, small and low key. With the demand for bats so much less then pitching, they could make several moves and really improve their lineup. Second, short, and catcher could be improved with some creative deals.
raysdaze
Pretty sure Rays are set at MIF with Hech, Beckham, Miller, Drob, and Ramos and Sucre at catcher are just fine. LHR and RH bat are the only real areas of need.
The_Porcupine
My point was to take advantage of the market values. Virtually no competition from other contenders for these positions and thus possibly buy low for upgrades.
Yes they need bullpen help too.
raysdaze
Yup, so who would be an (affordable) upgrade at SS or 2B?
myaccount
This is a difficult question, as the haul you or I might think would complete a deal could be anything but according to a GM. Conceivably, Cozart could be had seeing as he’s a rental, however I could also see Dick Williams holding on to him and offering a QO. Brandon Phillips may be available and low cost. Ian Kinsler, Marcus Semien, Yangervis Solarte, Howie Kendrick if somebody thinks he could still play 2B. There are guys out there that would be upgrades.
kc38
So get rid of the newly acquired gold glove playing hechavarria and kick Wilson Ramos to the curb
The_Porcupine
How are they hitting? I agree, the Fielding of hech is highly valuable, so I’ll revise a bit. 2b and catcher can be upgraded.
SimplyAmazin91
What would we realistically get from the Rays for him?
raysdaze
I’d imagine something in 15-20 range that need 40 man protection like chirinos, wood, Harris, Cuiffo, etc. plenty of depth on pitching side
Logjammer D"Baggagecling
Why?
Cheeseball
Because when the rays are playing the yanks in a one game playoff in NY
, this guy will flip one over the left field porch and make the Gm look smart.
agentx
Maybe TB can issue Duda the same No. 24 that Dan Johnson wore for good luck.
TwinsHomer
Dan Johnson doesn’t hit bombs anymore. He pitches the most deadly of knuckleballs
hiflew
I applaud the Rays for going for it against the big bad Sox and Yanks. It would have been easy to just sell off a couple of weeks ago and wait for next year, but they are going for it. You have to respect that.
Otownpr
Why? This doesn’t make any sense?
zclee06
Don’t see the point he’s batting 246 and is getting washed up.
LongTimeFan1
Zclee06 – Duda’s a very down to earth, humble, quiet guy with a beast of a build, with superb exit velocity and imposing plate presence. Your view of him, isn’t accurate. He’s dangerous every time he steps to the plate and especially during his hotstreaks when he can carry a team.
Of course the Batting Average could and should be better through reduced K’s and remembering to use the whole field which is key to elevating his game. When he does, he’s unstoppable. The Rays would be getting an asset with solid on base percentage and a player who can hit to all fields with power.
His defense is up and down, but overall average. He gets rusty defensively after long layoff. The key is good health and consistent playing time at first base. With that comes good scooping and saving his teammates a bunch of errors.
I like Duda and I feel sad for imminent Mets departure. And that this may be difficult on him emotionally. But it’s the right thing for the Mets to do with Dominc Smith ready for call up.
ralstar
Yes, his defense is bad, but he’s a career 122 wRC+ with a 127 wRC+ this year. For all those clamoring about “why”, it’s because he’s consistently a well above average offensive player who won’t cost a ton.
zclee06
If this deal happens the Mets will get the better deal automatically by just getting rid of him. Any ideas on what the Mets would get for him
jdgoat
Stop
jbigz12
Will don smith be called up immediately? Seems like he’s ready to go
rct
I think I read that both Rosario and Dom Smith will wait until after the deadline. Mets are going to place Bruce at first with Grandy at right to get them some time before they (hopefully) trade them. Then Rosario and Smith come up.
A'sfaninUK
Looks like a solid pickup, his bat works well in any lineup. Makes that Rays one even longer.
Otownpr
I would love this trade if it is for Kevin Cash!
Larry David's Joe Pepitone Jersey
Don’t listen to most of the Mets fans on Duda. He’s been a scapegoat for fans ever since Game 5 of the World Series two years ago.
He’s not a perfect player by any means – streaky, not great defensively – but he’s a capable middle of the order bat who gets on base.
Mr. Slave's Gerbil
Completely agree. He’s nothing too flashy, but he makes the Rays better at a cheap price.
jdgoat
This is a good take. He’s a valuable guy who can win you a game/series if he gets hot. You’re right that he’s not perfect, but it doesn’t make him not valuable
iamhector24
Mets fan here. He is a good professional hitter. The Met fan hate of Duda is fn stupid.
metsoptimist
Yes, the way he’s been treated since then is ridiculous. I wish “Lil’ Luke” well.
This breaking up of the team is painful, and I guess this is only the beginning.
hojostache
Duda should put up .900 OPS and be a great addition to the clubhouse. He is passsble at 1B, but as a DH I think he could mash. He’s streaky, but when he is hot he is scary good. Solid pickup for TB. It looks like the Mets hot fair value in Smith.
TB fans…Granderson has an instagram where he followed Duda around, it’s pretty funny and it gives a better look at how he is wvtgr guys (very well liked).
Duda definitely took an unfair amount of flack for the throw in the WS and as a player. He’s solid and w. a decent lineup he could make a big difference.
steelerbravenation
How could the Braves not look to package Phillips & Adams to the Rays maybe throw in a prospect or 2 and get a prospect back from them. They got good arms it seems that come up every year.
I hope Coppy doesn’t believe that we are contenders this year.
hiflew
Drew Smith is the guy they got from Detroit for Mikie Mahtook earlier this year. So essentially this is Mahtook for Duda. Not a bad deal if you look at it that way.
jbigz12
Not a bad deal either way. If drew smith ever reaches the bigs it will be as a mop up reliever. His ceiling is that of a middle reliever. So take Duda and hope he goes on a hot streak.
flex_savage
smith’s MLB ceiling is setup guy
jbigz12
Correct. Was thinking of the wrong guy here. Smith throws hard, not a bad return for NYM. That is my mistake
LongTimeFan1
His ceiling is much higher than middle reliever
Matt Galvin
So Trade Deadline starts today.
yukongold
Both Rays fans must be ecstatic.
Bullet
lol
evelandsrule
There’s dozens of us!
geejohnny
There’s more of us than anyone would guess. We just don’t like going to that embarrassing 4 ring circus of a park.
raysdaze
Oh man, that’s good stuff! Keep ’em coming boss!
Larry David's Joe Pepitone Jersey
What’s the scoop on Drew Smith?
Francys01
All I have to say is that it’s good for Tampa Bay Rays and the Yankees lost the opportunity of acquiring Lucas Dudas.
Bullet
The Mets weren’t trading with the Yankees anyway… No opportunity lost.
ctguy
Doubt the Yankees were going to trade for him anyway. Getting another 1st baseman is not that high on the priority list.
jeffball10
More wheeling and dealing from Tampa. They got Drew Smith for Mikie Mahtook (Who they were about to release). Drew Smith seems to be getting under appreciated by 2 different teams now despite decent draft pedigree and good numbers.
darkstar61
Hope Drew isn’t the only D. Smith making news off this deal
Let the Dominic era begin!
bravesfan88
I’ll forever miss the Braves playing Camptown Races whenever Lucas Duda comes up to bat, and his disgruntled look at how immature and played out it is..lol
In all seriousness though, the Rays got a good player in Duda…I’m sure he will definitely help their club. Not only from his presence in the line-up, but he’s also a good clubhouse veteran as well…
Congrats Rays and Rays’ fans…
Ironman_4life
As an Orioles fan this sucks. Why can’t we trade for a general manager that’s willing to make some trades
24TheKid
You can have Jerry Dipoto.
jbigz12
Duquette doesn’t have permission. We need to cash in on Brad brach right now, he’s a hot of a commodity as he’s ever going to be. I’d be open to dealing Donnie hart too I think we might get something halfway decent back for him considering the price of relievers these days. Britton needs to throw better though I feel like we’d be giving him away if we dealt him right now
jbigz12
I can guarantee you he doesn’t have the power to deal Jones or Machado either. Schoop, Machado, and Brach would turn the system from bottom 5 to top 5 if we decided to pull the trigger on those deals. I’d like for us to keep schoop though, I think he can be even better than he is right now. In a perfect world we’d deal Machado and brach this year and stock us up then flip Britton and jones next year when there may be a market for an outfielder. Not much else to deal though I think it’d be wise to keep givens and let him close once those 2 are gone. Wouldn’t want to deal Bundy either we need the pitching.
raysdaze
Top 5 LOL
jbigz12
If you don’t think trading Machado schoop and brach/Britton would give them a top 5 system tomorrow you are not very smart. Dealing Machado alone would put you in the top 10
raysdaze
Just for grins, let’s pretend that 1.5 years of Manny would net the same return as 3 years of Sale. Do you honestly believe that return would transorm the O’s system from one of the worst to a top 10? If so, id like to suggest passing that doobie to the left.
jbigz12
If you added the #1 prospect and the #12 prospect in baseball we’d be solid up top. That’d give us 3 in the top 30. The return on Machado at this point would be strong. If we got Torres, Sheffield and Florial that’d give us 4 top 100 prospects which would put us into the top half of the league. Probably not top 10 But easily in the top 15. 4 guys in the top 100 would put us in that range. BR has the orioles at 23 now.. if the Yankees could get Machado tomorrow I don’t think they’d have a hard time giving up that package and it’d be almost a certainty he’d resign there.
raysdaze
Youre suggesting a larger return for 1.5 years of a (stud) 3B who’s having a down year by his standard, compared to double the service time for the best pitcher in baseball, right? Def not apples to apples and even with that return, no way O’s system is anywhere near top 10! Rays have 7 top 100 prospects (and the system is so deep well likely lose a handful of solid guys to rule 5, just like every year). and are barely top 10. Sounds like you’re thinking the number of top 100 prospects distates rankings while neglecting depth.
dodgerfan711
This Drew Smith has incredible numbers.
pickandersen
Boston misses out on yet another player…a first baseman this time. So no Duda…Votto to BOS?
jbigz12
They aren’t taking on Vottos deal they’re still swallowing panda’s and Allen Craig’s and rusney castillo’s
dodgerfan711
Why would the red sox need a 1B moreland is doing just fine. Every article there is a red sox fan mad they cant get every signle player. And no votto to boston is unrealistic
frankthetank1985
good luck doodie bags!!! U were a nice player for the Mets and made me look really smart since I was on team Duda in the Duda vs Davis debate a few years back. And yes, I have a Duda jersey because of it. Time to retire that one. Good luck and hopefully this pitcher they got for you is something of value over the next couple of years.
BAT1126
I’m gonna miss “The Dude” but Rays fans when he gets hot he can carry a team for a week to 10 days. We’ve seen it happen enough times. You have a winner. Now it’s time to watch the Smith’s turn in NYC.
El Duderino
Don’t worry. I’m still here.
mergspvy
Lucas is the latest Met to escape the curse of David Wrong. the last two? Justin Turner, Daniel Murphy
morebreakdowns
What does this even mean?
daviebatz
Leaving the mets guarantees him leading the league in hitting. (See murphy and turner)
morebreakdowns
Duda, can carry your team for 2 weeks and can go dormant for a month. I also have never seen a player hit more meaningless hrs as this guy has, if you look into that kind of thing. That being said he is still a quality player that should have commanded more if this was an average 1b market, but Jennings has some reliever upside something the Mets definitely need
Monkey’s Uncle
Adam LaRoche to me will always be the king of meaningless homers, which is odd because he was a somewhat similar player to Duda. I think just about all of LaRoche’s homers as a Pirate came as solo shots when the Bucs were behind by 6 runs in the 9th inning.
jmdjr1966
Jennings didn’t go to the Mets…
Duda may strike out a lot but he will work walks his Homers are meaningful usually. Meaningless Homers are once in the last three innings of a game when you are winning by 3 or more runs or losing big.
His range is limited but his error count is low and he is tall and scoops out balls in the dirt pretty well. His foot work around the bag is actually good.
Dutch Vander Linde
The Mets just gave a good player for free