The Athletics have designated veteran catcher Stephen Vogt for assignment in the team’s latest future-oriented move, per a club announcement. Catcher Bruce Maxwell and first baseman/outfielder Matt Olson have been called up from Triple-A, with third baseman Matt Chapman hitting the DL.
[RELATED: Updated Athletics Depth Chart]
Chapman had only just been called up himself, taking over at third base with veteran Trevor Plouffe being designated and later traded to the Rays. The A’s are now calling upon two additional youthful players while making the somewhat surprising decision to part with Vogt — one of the organization’s longest-tenured players.
Vogt earned All-Star nods in each of the past two seasons. He was also a fan favorite and noted clubhouse leader in Oakland. But the 32-year-old was struggling early in 2017. Through 174 plate appearances, he owns a marginal .217/.287/.357 batting line with four home runs.
Despite those tepid results, it stands to reason that the left-handed hitter will draw interest from other organizations. Vogt is earning just $2,965,000 this year and has two arb-eligible seasons still to come. It seems possible, though hardly certain, that he could be claimed on waivers; more likely, perhaps, is some kind of trade.
Vogt’s difficulties at the plate are only part of the story. After all, he has been a bit unlucky to carry a .244 BABIP — though his 28.3% soft contact rate also represents a low point. But there are also questions about his defensive capabilities behind the dish; Baseball Prospectus (subscription required) continues to rate Vogt as a negative in the pitch-framing department while also grading him as below-average in controlling the running game. Vogt has also played first base and a bit of corner outfield in the past, so he does come with some defensive versatility.
Whatever happens with Vogt, the A’s seem clearly to be open for business with regards to other veteran players. First baseman Yonder Alonso, righty Sonny Gray, and infielder Jed Lowrie all seem to be clear trade candidates along with relievers Ryan Madson, Sean Doolittle, and Santiago Casilla — among other players.
While exploring deals in a market that currently features relatively few clear sellers, the A’s will begin to see what they have in some younger options. Maxwell, 26, has already tasted the majors in each of the past two years and has slashed a robust .310/.378/.516 over 312 total plate appearances at the highest level of the minors (after largely scuffling at the plate earlier in his professional career). The 23-year-old Olson has also received brief MLB time already. He has dominated the PCL pitching thus far in 2017, putting up a .271/.365/.561 batting line with 17 home runs through 249 trips to the plate on the year.
ericl97
oh wow.
pickandersen
Jeff, any rumors about Lavarnway being called up?
arc89
Somebody will pick him up as a back up catcher. If only he would not be so stubborn and try to pull every pitch. Teams do a shift on him and he still doesn’t hit opposite field.
djtommyaces
White sox
Chucky25
wow, didn’t see that coming,but I have been looking forward to seeing Maxwell be given the chance, along with Olson
zacharydmanprin
About 200 games too late to make any difference. The fact that Vogt was ever an All Star, let alone twice is proof that the All Star Game means nothing.
Priggs89
I thought Kyle Schwarber being top 10 for outfielders this year was proof.
RiverCatsFilms
That’s a surprise
A'sfaninUK
I’ve never seen a player play catcher like he does, it’s almost like he doesn’t know how to catch a ball that isn’t thrown directly at him, no one takes more direct body shots than him. He’s flat out awful there. Might be able to fix the bat, but he honestly should just take the rest of the year off to help his body out.
Gerald_pinstripe
Vogt as a solution for the Yankees at first??
A'sfaninUK
Alonso is a better one, but he’s going to cost Dustin Fowler.
cubsfan2489
Once again Alonzo won’t demand Fowler. A guy who had been below average having one career year, isn’t going to demand a top prospect! Stop trolling and go away!
arc89
Fowler is not a top prospect. Frazier is their top prospect. Rutherford is ahead of Fowler on their OF prospect list. Fowler is the yanks #8 prospect. He lacks the power in his bat and OBA. More likely a 4th outfielder on most teams.
cubsfan2489
Alonso*
Nick k
Yankees could potential buy him from Oakland and try it out. Can’t hurt any worse at 1st base, and he’s a great club house guy. I think it’s a low risk, high reward move.
I have no interest in Alonso… he’s a guy have his one year of his career… was nothing before this season.
A'sfaninUK
Did you say that about Donaldson, Turner & JD Martinez too? Because Alonso is simply doing what they did. Take ONE second to learn about trends and you’ll understand that Alonso is a .900+ OPS guy from here on out.
realgone2
“Please cease and desist your repeated, targeted harassment of my posts on this site ” Now that’s comedy gold.
chesteraarthur
He said a top prospect, not the top prospect. And Frazier is not their top prospect, Torres is. Fowler is a 50fv prospect, that is certainly a top prospect when talking about them league wide. Using the fact that the Yankees have another really high rated OF prospect as some method do devalue Fowler is a pretty poor argument.
chesteraarthur
Did you say that about all the guys who did just have 1 good year? Oh, those don’t fit your narrative so you leave them out? Gotcha. get up on outta heeeeere
myaccount
Fowler is so overrated. Nothing special at all, even in the minors.
myaccount
A lot of people on here fail to see why Alonso is having a career year. He’s made adjustments. He’s tweaked his swing– his bat plane is different, he’s hitting with back spin, etc. If he has a similar second half and pitchers haven’t found a way to adjust to him, it’s a good bet that he’ll have a productive rest of his career. People will down vote this which is fine but I’ll trust the fangraphs heads over random MLBTR posters who disagree.
I Believe We Can Win
1st good year ever, possible regression candidate, free agent at seasons end whom they cant extend a QO…..
More like
Yankees get Alonso and Casilla
A’s get Austin Clarkin and Florial
A’s get a cheaper longer control player in Austin and talent in Clarkin and Florial while Yankees solve their 1B issue and pick up a depth piece for the pen with a history of being a ground ball pitcher.
A'sfaninUK
lol that trade is worthless to both teams
arc89
the A’s can extend Alonso with QO at the end of the year. Just surprised that fans think Fowler is a high prospect when he is more of a defensive 4th outfielder..
I Believe We Can Win
And trading dustin fowler is worthless to the yankees for yonder alonso given his lack of history, lack of team control, and surplus of 1B options the yankees have.
The yankees need production from 3B more than they need 1B.
Here’s cheaper options the yankees could pursue for 1B than giving up Fowler.
Tyler Austin who’s raking at triple A, justin morneau who slashed .261/.303/.429 with the white sox last year, Lucas Duda Matt Adams come with 1 more year of control Danny Valencia Eric Hosmer are also rentals you could trade for howie kendrick who’s a rental and toss him at 1st.
Thats 7 options the yankees have to choose from who would cost less than what you want for alonso and still give the yankees necessary production from 1st.
I Believe We Can Win
Meant if yankees trade for alonso the yankees cant extend him a QO.
At least when the yankees traded beltran to the rangers for tate Beltran had quite a history of success as a hitter. Alonso doesnt have the track record.
Nick k
When Yankees traded Beltran they got Texas 15th best prospect. I would not give up a top 30 prospect for Alonso
chesteraarthur
surprised you think you’re a better prospect evaluator than Eric Longenhagen
cubsfan2489
Castro has had a history of being able to hit. Has he been up and down? Yes. However, I’m sure that if he were put on the block, there would be plenty of teams interested. Alonso has never hit nearly as well as Castro. Heck, he’s never hit nearly as well as one Ryan Theriot. He’s done NOTHING in his career. Stop putting dumb “information” out there and stating that they’re facts. When, in reality, (everyone else’s except you and westcoastdumbdumb) it is just your opinion and have no facts to back any of it up. So JAF, what you’ve just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having to read it. May God have mercy on your soul.
mstrchef13
Do QOs still exist?
arc89
Duda, Valencia, and Adams are terrible defensive first basemen. Alonso is a above average 1B so you also get defense with him which the other 3 are liabilities on the field. Second if you were trading for Hosmer or Adams they will probably cost you Fowler or even a better prospect. As for Austin he would be up right now if the yanks felt he is ready.
I Believe We Can Win
Alonso is above average defensively? According to who?
fangraphs.com/statss.aspx?playerid=2530&posit…
Alonso has literally registered a defensive rating of -4 or worse according to fan graphs 5 of his 7 seasons.
Also, in a deal for hosmer looking at the royals farm according to mlb I’d think they prioritize pitching as such I think they headliner is a hosmer deal would would be in on Littell and Clarkin and someone like chance adams. Given hosmers track record as a hitter itd be a better deal than going after alonso.
As for adams. What the braves gave up for him theyd be happy to triple their investmemt. Austin Wade and Solak would entice the braves to deal adams who have stock piled pitching and could use some hitters who are near or at mlb ready.
I Believe We Can Win
For comparison sakes alonso is above average compared to others, but hes actually an ok defensive first baseman. But youre not putting your best defensive player at 1st to begin with.
Of all positions 1st has the least amount of defensive runs saved compared to all other positions who field the ball.
Defense is nice for 1st but it certainly isnt mandatory in this league and if youre expecrting people to pay more cause of defense thatd work of it was ss, cf, 3b not so much 1st.
arc89
Alonso rated below average at 3B but above average at 1B. He is a
better 1B than Hosmer. So go ahead throw a DH at 1B like in carter right now. next you will say fangraphs rank Carter ahead of Alonso.
Glad you think the yanks are going to get players for their low prospects. Good luck to that.
Ben10
Ehhhhh…..Valencia isn’t terrible defensively. He’s just below average. When I think of terrible, I think Jesus Montero or Daniel Vogelbach.
I Believe We Can Win
1. Chance Adams is hovering around top 100 prospect lists and is pitching lights out in triple A. Ian Clarkin is a former 1st round pick back in 2013 pitching well in double A. And Zach Littell is kind of a wildcard pitching well in the low minors. “low prospects” you could at least look up the players before commenting.
2. He’s not “above average” at 1B- you really need to learn how these things work. Posting negative ratings doesn’t make you above average. -4.4, -8.2, -3.8, -1.4, -4.8. -11, -5.2 negative ratings on your defense isn’t above average- it is entirely possible for post a positive defensive rating at 1B. Comparing Alonso to Eric Hosmer Chris Carter Edwin Encarnarcion David Ortiz Ryan Howard who are horrendous 1B defensively, yes he is above average COMPARED to others. OVERALL he isn’t. Please, go take a stat class or something.
3. Yonder Alonso officially became a full time starter in 2012. From 2012- 2016 here are 1B who have done worse defensively than Alonso minimum 4500 innings at 1st- Chris Davis, Joey Votto, Paul Goldschmidt, Freddie Freeman- see a trend here? Ok lets go 3000 innings at 1st That would include Morneau, Fielder, Abreu, Reynolds. Notice how all these players have been better hitters in their career than Alonso. Teams aren’t prioritizing 1st base defense. 1st base defense is about as important as whether an outfielder is right or left handed.
The Yankees are looking at two things: Who’s cheaper and who’s got the track record or a history to justify giving up pieces. They are 100% not concerned with 1st base defense. If they were concerned with 1st base defense they would of signed Daric Barton who’s only 31 and a well regarded defensively…….not chris carter.
cazzatta
Yes, yes, yes.
Nick k
That was my first thought exactly… can’t be any worse that’ll chris carter
mchaney317 2
He definitely shouldn’t be catching anymore and he’s making a lot more weak contact this year, but his walks are up, he still doesn’t strike out a lot, and his BABIP points to some positive regression, so someone’s gonna get him as a bench bat and be glad they did it
A'sfaninUK
He is a fantastic clubhouse guy, if a team is looking for a solid 25th man who can play LF, 1B and DH – he’s a great pickup. Just don’t start him.
arc89
Your going to miss those slow grounders to first base that Vogt always hits.
mchaney317 2
Right after I posted this, I noticed that the article was changed to add a lot of the details I mentioned. Maybe Jeff really does notice me :’)
kaido24
They always post a quick blurb as soon as news hits, then edit to add more info.
mchaney317 2
Well yeah, but I just thought it was interesting how close that paragraph was to my comment…let me have my moment
julyn82001
This is terrible but understand the business side of it…
A'sfaninUK
“Vogt’s difficulties at the plate are only part of the story. After all, he has been a bit unlucky to carry a .244 BABIP ”
Its not luck, its horrendous hitting. He hits into the shift without fail! Of course his babip is going to be low, its his horrible approach at the plate that caused that.
crazysull
This shows how players(especially catchers) that when they hit a certain age their production hits a wall and drops off a cliff. I could see this coming, the Athletics are a team that are trying to get younger and give their young players a chance and they fee like their young options at catcher would be an upgrade over Vogt and his time finally ran out. I do however believe that he won’t be in DFA limbo/free agency for long, some team in need of a catcher/1st baseman and a veteran presence will look to scoop him up
Yamsi12
“I believe in Stephen Vo……..oh wait.”
A'sfaninUK
“….oh its not 2014 anymore and age caught up to him.”
crazysull
I think this was the Athletics plan all along. Sign veterans and keep their own for a little less than half a season and then let them go and replace them with rookies after they got a little more seasoning in the minors and won’t occur enough service time giving them one extra year before they are eligible for free agency. By the end of the year, players like Alonso and Grey and Lowrie and their back end of the bullpen guys to make room for their young prospects. I see them keeping some veterans around, the ones that they feel like they won’t get a lot for and are better off keeping, they can help mentor the young players so they can take over next season. Players like Rosales, and Davis would be smart to keep since they provide good depth and Rosales can play all over the infield and Davis is a speedster and they don’t have anyone else really ready to take over in center for them right now. If I were to guess Matt Joyce’s days are numbered there with Matt Olsen already up with the team
nste23
He signed a two year contract and has been a hot hitter, and Matt Olson is not an everyday player in the MLB yet.
A'sfaninUK
Joyce is a fine bench player/4th OF and he does have a 2 year deal. I totally can see Olson getting the bulk of the playing time and Joyce doing a lot of pinch hitting in the 2nd half.
sacball
They just need to give Olson consistent playing time.
nste23
I agree
sacball
He should have been designated strictly for having an awful Skillet song as his walk up music for 4 or 5 years now
bleacherbum
The Padres could be a sneaky waiver wire claim for Vogt. We still don’t know how long Hedges will be out after the Rizzo slide and you have the 21 year old rule V pick Luis Torrens logging all of the innings behind the dish right now which probably isn’t the best alternative in the world. Vogt could help in the short term there, and not to mention Solarte just went down which has caused Pirela to move his hot bat from LF to 2B freeing up playing time for Vogt in LF as well possibly? Just thinking outside the box since the Padres do have #3 waiver wire priority with injuries at the positions he can play.
bleacherbum
Not to mention AJ Preller and his obsession with catchers. Carried 4 on the opening day roster and drafted one in the second round and another in the third round of last weeks draft.
I Believe We Can Win
No.
Pirela playing 2nd is fine. Torrens starting is fine.
Toss cordoba out there in LF, put aybar back at ss, sczur is the 4th OF rotation guy and d arnaud is infield depth.
Call up bethancourt with diaz probably hitting the DL with that forearm strain which could wind up being a 60 day DL stint.
jakeperrow
Could see the mariners backing him up to Zunino, Ruiz has provided very little
dstuart
I guess the A’s DON’T believe in Stephen Vogt
GarryHarris
Nothing about the Oakland A’s team makes sense. Every player is either old or a high risk-medium reward project.
rycm131
The loss of Vogt and Reddick hurt much more in the club house than on the field. It’s similar to Nick Swisher, some players are good team builders and hurt to get rid of them. That being said Oakland should unload and add as many prospects as possible as their “let’s just build the best bullpen ever” theory didn’t work.
A'sfaninUK
That being said none of those guys led the team to a title, so keeping them around only fosters a losing attitude, which they currently have now.
davidcoonce74
Nick Swisher was always the most unliked player in baseball. Nobody liked that guy