It’s been 342 professional appearances and nearly eight calendar years since Ryan Dennick was selected by the Royals out of Tennessee Technological University in 2009. We’re happy to welcome Ryan as the latest author to join our Player’s Perspective series here at MLBTR.
18,910. This is the number of players who have made a Major League debut in the history of the sport. In life, you only get a few true indelible moments. For those nearly 19,000 players, there is no doubt in my mind getting the call to the big leagues is one of them. Every single player that has been lucky enough to beat incredible odds to reach the game’s highest level can tell you in vivid detail where they were, when it happened, and the emotions that came with having a lifelong dream realized. My name is Ryan Dennick. I was a 22nd-round senior sign in the 2009 draft. Six seasons later, I became number 18,360. This was my indelible moment.
On August 31st, 2014, Jonathan Broxton was traded from the Cincinnati Reds to the Milwaukee Brewers. To most, this meant the Reds were shedding a little over $11MM in payroll commitment. For a team that was in desperate need of salary relief, it was a move they had to make. To the players in Triple-A Louisville’s clubhouse, this meant something completely different. There was an open 40-man roster spot.
When news of the trade broke, a bit of a buzz swept through the clubhouse. The move was completely unexpected and guys began to speculate who could fill the vacancy. With rosters in the big leagues expanding from 25 to 40 the next day, that roster spot wouldn’t be vacant very long. Each year, you can take a pretty good guess on who most of the September call-ups are going to be. Players already on the 40-man roster in the upper minors obviously have the inside track to get the call, since no roster move needs to be made. Prospects that require being protected from the Rule 5 draft the upcoming offseason could certainly find themselves in a Major League uniform come September.
Then there are players like me. The hardest call-ups to predict. The non-prospect, roster filler types that had their best statistical seasons. If a spot isn’t open on the 40-man, teams don’t often go out of their way to create an opening for a player who probably doesn’t fit into their long-term plans. Instead, these players will be sent into the offseason with a pat on the back for a job well done, and perhaps an invite to Major League Spring Training the next season. A team’s placement in the standings plays a factor as well. Without the added pressure of staying in contention late in the season, teams out of the race may be more willing to reward these players with a call-up, if a roster spot is available. The Reds were the perfect storm. Sitting with a record of 66-71, they were out of contention. When the Broxton trade happened, a roster spot opened up. Every player in our clubhouse not currently on the 40-man roster was hoping that spot had their name on it.
For a good majority of my minor league pitching career, I was quite mediocre statistically. I was never great, but never horrible either. I had always shown enough promise to warrant filling a minor league roster spot. But in the eyes of those in the front office, I probably didn’t have enough “stuff” to reach the Majors without great minor league numbers to force their hand. Of course, being left-handed helped me stick around, too. I always believed I would reach the Majors one day. Every minor leaguer does. We would be crazy to live the minor league lifestyle year after year if we didn’t think we could reach the carrot on the stick, even if it was just a nibble.
For whatever reason, a player can have a year where everything just goes right. Something just clicks. Pitchers see line drives hit right at fielders. Hitters have more bloopers fall in for hits. That was my 2014 season. I was having easily the best season of my life. Outing after outing, I was building my case to force the Reds to make a decision on me. A move from the starting rotation to the bullpen helped my fastball play up a little more and made my slider a little sharper. Every bit helps. By the end of the season, my 40-man roster spot résumé included an unblemished record, a team-low ERA, the league lead in appearances, and the league lead in holds. Seemingly every break went my way. I was hoping for one more.
On the morning of September 1, I rolled into Louisville Slugger Field a little later than I normally do. I had just finished a long breakfast with my mom and fiancé at one of the local spots in downtown Louisville. I tried all I could to get my mind off what could be waiting for me when I arrived. I failed. Expecting a call-up was an easy way to set yourself up for disappointment so I always tried to operate with the idea that if I was meant to be in the big leagues, somehow I would get there. But the Broxton trade cleared a path. That spot has to go to someone. Why not me?
As I walked through the clubhouse doors, to the left I already saw our manager, Jim Riggleman, in his office letting the members of the 40-man roster know they are getting the call back to the Majors. Since I was one of the last players to arrive in the clubhouse, I set my bag down at my locker and took a quick look around the room looking for unbridled happiness from a player who earned the right to fill the open roster spot.
It doesn’t matter if a player has been to the big leagues before or not, when a teammate gets called up for the first time, it’s a special moment in the clubhouse. Everyone stops what they are doing to offer handshakes and hugs in recognition of the hard work, dedication and sacrifice it takes to reach the game’s highest level. Major League jobs aren’t given away. Every single one of them is earned. However, no such excitement was taking place. I left my locker to head towards the players’ lounge to try to get in a game of spades before heading out to the field to do my throwing program. Right as I turned the corner, I was met by our pitching coach, Ted Power. “Where have you been?! Skip wants to see you! Now!”
When the manager wants to see you, it’s usually for one of three reasons. You’re either going up, going down, or going home. It’s not to chit-chat. As I made my way to Riggleman’s office, I passed another player who was just told he was returning to the big leagues. We didn’t say anything as we passed. He just shot me a wink, as if he already knew what I was about to walk into. “Have a seat, Ryan,” Jim said. I took a seat on the sofa in his office as I wondered if this was it.
“Am I going up? Is he letting me know they decided not to call me up but he’s thanking me for a great season?” My mind raced so fast that I didn’t realize he’d been talking for about ten seconds, and I didn’t hear anything he said. I snapped out of it and zoned back in to catch him say, “So you’re going up to Cincinnati to finish out the season. Do you have any questions?”
I sat in stunned silence, trying to process what has just been said to me. I’d waited my whole life to hear those words and now that I had, I didn’t know what to do. Years of low pay: validated. Years of sub-par housing: validated. Years of cramped 12-hour bus rides: validated. Years of eating more peanut butter and jelly than is recommended in a lifetime: validated. “…No,” I said. I could barely eek that out.
“OK, then get out of here, Jimmy (the trainer) has your itinerary.”
I left his office, and right around the corner was the player I passed on my way in. “Yeah??” he asked, referring to me being called up or not. I nodded my head. “Yeah…” He turned to go into the clubhouse and shouted,“We got a first-timer here!” Handshakes and hugs all around. I just became a 27-year-old rookie.
Photo courtesy of USA Today Sports Images.
partyatnapolis
these stories are awesome. i love seeing this side of the game we hardly get to see. honestly i’d never heard of him, but i enjoyed reading his story. this is why i visit MLBTR above all others. great info and awesome stuff from players perspectives.
davealden53
Great story well told. Thanks for sharing.
TheMichigan
Ryan, very well thought and written article, I love the guests that MLBTR gets. It’s simply amazing to have a free view into the minds of actual former/current major leaguers.
Getting called up to the Majors is just a dream for some people, and some people will sacrifice family time, education, jobs etc etc to achieve that dream they have held in their hearts since they were old enough to play baseball. Every ballplayer wants/dreams of that “meeting with skip” that could send them on their course for the future. This article truly encapsulates the passion and sacrifice that is required to earn a roster spot on a team in the highest level of baseball in the world.
We all have wanted to add one to 18,910 and you have done what many have dreamed.
schellis 2
Even if he never makes it to the majors again, he will always be able to call himself a major league player.
TJECK109
Awesome read. Gave me goosebumps trying to imagine that feeling you had when your dream became reality. Welcome aboard and keep up the good work.
PS: you only get one MLB trade rumors debut too and it was a good one
brewpackbuckbadg
I see that Ryan was part of the rule five draft. Is there a way to find out what level it was? Did he ever get returned to Kansas City?
Steve Adams
He was drafted in the Triple-A phase of the 2012 Rule 5 Draft and stayed in the Reds org from 2013-15. The Dodgers claimed him off waivers in April 2015, and he spent most of that year with them.
brewpackbuckbadg
Thanks Steve. May I ask where you got this info?
Dookie Howser, MD
June 9, 2009: Drafted by the Kansas City Royals in the 22nd round of the 2009 amateur draft. Player signed June 14, 2009.
December 6, 2012: Drafted by the Cincinnati Reds from the Kansas City Royals in the 2012 rule 5 draft.
April 15, 2015: Selected off waivers by the Los Angeles Dodgers from the Cincinnati Reds.
November 6, 2015: Granted Free Agency.
Monkey’s Uncle
2016: Pitched for the Lancaster (PA) Barnstormers of the independent Atlantic League. As many former big-league prospects play in the Indy leagues or overseas hoping to earn another big league contract, I’d be curious to know if he’s still planning on playing at age 30.
Great article.
bbgods
Love this! Welcome to the team, Ryan. Looking forward to more of your writing.
jimoore67
Excellent story, with 18,910 players I’m curious who is considered the first MLB player?
Abner Doubleday?
HubcapDiamondStarHalo
I’m gonna guess it’s much like the first HOFer… You can probably narrow it down to the guys who were on the first teams in the first official professional league, but distilling it much beyond that might be tough.
schellis 2
It would seem to be Deacon White or anyone else that played in that first game
baseball-reference.com/players/w/whitede01.shtml
babyk79
Awesome read!
hojostache
Great write-up. Good voice, pace, perspective, etc.
I look forward to future articles .
sddew
I love reading these behind the scenes stories from a player’s perspective. Thanks to Ryan for adding a positive and good read after a day of such horrible bad news in the game. Well done…
BlueSkyLA
You have excellent “stuff” Ryan!
Deke
This is a great story, loved reading it. I’d like to hear “Part 2” what happened next? We don’t see what happens. Do they go and pack up their whole house? Send someone else to do it? Where do they live? All that stuff is HARD to do when you have to walk into an MLB clubhouse the next day.
TheMichigan
He pitched to a 11 ERA with 3 Ks
Still it’s amazing to live your dream
Kirby34
Fantastic, Ryan. Thank you for giving us a sense of what that’s like.
Just John
Ryan, thanks for the great story. Perspectives like these are part of the one facet of baseball that I wish I could understand more. “Moneyball’ was a great read, but paints a much more gruesome picture. I love your bright side.
You also reminded me of a question I’ve had for some time now. I noticed you were up long enough to give up a couple long balls 🙂 A friend of a friend of another retired pitcher told me he said “a guy never forgets who takes him yard’.. Is that true? Just curious who gotcha.
Thanks again for sharing.
Monkey’s Uncle
I looked that up but I’m guessing by the phrasing of your question that you hope that Ryan answers it himself, so I’ll refrain from giving the correct response unless asked. If you want to know yourself and know where to look for that specific info in the site, click the link on Ryan Dennick’s name in the first sentence in this article, it takes you straight to his page at baseball reference.com…
Just John
@connfyoozed Thanks for the courtesy in not wanting to spoil a reply!. I’ve spent a great deal of time on Baseball-Reference looking over season-specific stat lines on main player pages but never had a reason to dig deeper into game-by-game or play-by-play sequences until now. I had no idea every single out was available there to sift through. Thanks for the illumination (I now have exponentially more material to procrastinate with)..
However, I also couldn’t help myself to know either….
Alas, Ryan, I imagine your meeting with Curtis Granderson is quite memorable. Perhaps even more so because of the intense and angry smirk he always wears at the plate. I’ve always thought he was as ‘smirky’ as anyone While I’m sure it’s only his ‘focused face’, I’m still intimidated as a mere spectator.
So your secrets out, Ryan, but any further insight you have on the pitcher-batter mental games with regards to homers and K’s would be awesome. Either way, awesome read.
jd396
Cool story!
MatthewBaltimore23
That’s awesome! Thanks for telling this story!
jagonza
Great read thank you for sharing it with us. You may not have had the longest career but You should know that I would trade my best day at my job for the worst day at yours.
deadmanonleave
Just brilliant. Thanks Ryan!
seillihp
Nice piece. Very well done Ryan.
pjmcnu
Great story! Congrats on reaching the mountaintop! Nobody can take it away from you.
IloveMACfootball
Well written. Most of the former player stuff is kinda lame, they just aren’t good storytellers, but this was great.
stratcrowder
Thanks Ryan! And thanks again from our great city of Louisville for giving us a tremendous season that year!
porcelena
Thank you for sharing this story. This is exactly why I LOVE BASEBALL!
CONGRATS TO YOU SIR! (my favorite team too)
Don
oldskool10to6
Great read Ryan, thanks for sharing. Being a lifelong fan, and in better days a player, I always wanted to hear stories like this. Such sacrifice one must give to make it to their dream for the proverbial cup of coffee. I would love for someone to compile stories like this from hall of famers to the guy who gets that one at bat or one third of an inning and are never heard from again. The stories of how a player had to negotiate to get his first home run ball back. That first K of an All Star. There are some great stories out there and glad that you shared yours Ryan.
HayesWilson
I love these and I think the guys at MLBTR would be very wise to continue them with more players and ex-players because I’m guessing there are many more interesting stories to be told