Reports suggest that there are three teams currently pursuing free agent righty Yovani Gallardo. We heard yesterday that the Rockies were lining up to participate in talks, and SB Nation’s Chris Cotillo suggested today on Twitter that the Orioles and Astros have also remained involved.
But Baltimore executive VP of baseball operations Dan Duquette said earlier this morning that the club is strongly disinclined to part with its top draft choice (currently 14th overall). And the club does not appear willing to go to a fourth year for Gallardo, Roch Kubatko of MASNsports.com reports. Houston, too, would need to punt a valuable pick (18th overall). While it’s long been expected that those clubs would consider starting pitching additions, and could still stand to do so, that added disincentive poses a significant barrier.
As for the Rockies, Gallardo’s agent, Bobby Witt, tells MLB.com’s Thomas Harding that his client would “be happy pitching for any of the three teams” — apparently suggesting that the specter of Coors Field won’t deter the veteran. Indeed, the Rockies are participating in “serious” talks with Gallardo, Patrick Saunders of the Denver Post reports on Twitter. But he adds that the club does not currently have an offer outstanding, and GM Jeff Bridich downplayed the link in public comments.
Unlike the other two teams, the Rockies would not have to give up their top choice — the fourth selection in this summer’s draft — to add Gallardo, who requires compensation because he turned down a qualifying offer from the Rangers. Attracting pitchers to throw at altitude has always been a challenge, of course, but that beneficial draft situation and a somewhat slow-to-develop market for Gallardo could leave the Rockies in solid position to make a move.
The fit for Colorado is obvious: while the organization has some potentially valuable arms, their rotation is as unsettled as any in the majors. There are questions up and down the staff: Jorge De La Rosa is steady but aging; Jordan Lyles and Tyler Chatwood are coming off of significant injuries; and Chad Bettis had a surprisingly solid 2015 but hardly has a deep track record. Younger options such as Jon Gray, Eddie Butler, and Tyler Matzek have shown talent but are hardly sure things, while Jeff Hoffman, Tyler Anderson, and others may be in need of further seasoning before they’re considered at the MLB level.
From a payroll perspective, the Rockies already have about $91MM on the books for the coming season and will still need to add the arbitration salaries of Charlie Blackmon (between $3.9MM and $2.7MM arb filings) and DJ LeMahieu ($3.3MM vs. $2.8MM). Of course, after signing Gerardo Parra, the club seems in position to deal an outfielder, and that could bring some salary relief along with a return in players. The team has never reached the $100MM threshold on an Opening Day roster.
Gallardo, who’ll soon turn 30, has turned in excellent results of late and is quite durable. But his peripherals are on the decline — in particular, a plummeting strikeout rate — and he’s now one of only three starters among MLBTR’s top fifty free agents who have yet to sign. (The others, Mat Latos and Doug Fister, figure to be available on shorter deals.) MLBTR’s Tim Dierkes predicted a four-year, $52MM salary entering the winter. It is fair to note that we’ve seen other pitchers — Ubaldo Jimenez, Matt Garza — reach that level of salary at this stage of the offseason or later. And there’s no denying that the market for starting pitching has been robust.
SoCalShu
No pitcher is going to come out publicly and say they are eskurd to pitch for Colorado. If it comes down to even money and even team competitiveness I see most pitchers shying away.
jaysfan1994
Nobody wants to pitch in Coors because they’re not competitive enough to draw any pitchers there on anything but an overpaid contract. Most teams are like this, you still have to offer the top dollar.
baseballrat
How soon you forget your team was full of Overpaid contracts for years. I guess having a playoff year makes you forget the last 20. Not many people wanted to pitch in T.O. Until after the trade deadline. Glass houses
Ray Ray
When was the last time the Rockies overpaid for a pitcher? Answer: never. Even the big contracts for Hampton and Neagle 15 years ago were pretty close to market value for them.
Mark 20
to be fair, when was the last time any big time pitcher signed with colarado in the last 10 years?
Ray Ray
None have signed since Hampton and Neagle. But that is because the Rockies owners publicly refused to sign any more quality free agent pitchers after those failures. They have somewhat backed off of that stance now. The Rox will never sign a David Price level guy, but a Gallardo/Chen/Kazmir level guy I could see them getting approval for.
kingjenrry
At the same time, all else being equal, a pitcher would rather pitch in Not Coors than in Coors. I think the Rockies are going with the right strategy by developing their own high K% pitchers within the organization and think they should double down on high-defense, high-contact players, Kansas City-style. Those are the guys who should be least affected by the differences in how the ball breaks at home vs away, and should be the ones best able to play to the expansive playing surface. Guys like Kevin Pillar would be ideal.
Dock_Elvis
I agree on everything you state, but I’ll just say that a #2ish guy like Gallardo would be a boon to the Rockies rotation. Just to have some potential quality innings eaten. Usually that guy they get is the back end type veteran. Sort or the same scenario played out in KC when they acquired Shields.
Ray Ray
I’m pretty sure that professional athletes are not as scared (even privately) as you might think. Most people become athletes because they like to face and beat challenges, not to find the safest and easiest path to glory.
redking
That’s an old-fashioned attitude. Today they are scared.
Ray Ray
Thank you for the 21st century update. I’ll go back to tending my cotton gin now.
gorav114
It seems that if they can get from under the remainder of Cargo salary they could pay enough to Gallardo to stay under their self imposed limit and bring in a nice prospect. Looks like the best play. I think for him to consider their though it would have to be more than he would get anywhere else. My prediction for him is either a 4/48-52 deal with CO or a 3/33 with the Os.
Ray Ray
I would love a 4/48 deal for Gallardo. I also think it could be done without trading CarGo. The big question is how long Jose Reyes is going to be suspended for. If he is suspended for a long time, that might pay for Gallardo’s salary by itself. Reyes is making 22MM this season. If he gets a half season suspension, there’s almost enough by itself.
cmb1974
I don’t see the O’s going for this pitcher. But might go for CarGo if they can get him without trading Kevin
Ray Ray
I doubt that it can be done without Gausman. The Rox have wanted him badly for at least two years now.
cmb1974
The O’s think he will be a #1 or 2 pitcher so I doubt there will be a trade
Ray Ray
I doubt it too, but to be honest, I would much rather keep CarGo. He is my favorite player after all.
seamaholic 2
Not Cargo, but I bet they can get Blackmon for Bundy or Harvey.
cmb1974
Harvey not going anywhere
AC_Slater123 2
Haha! Blackmon? Solid player, not enough for O’s to give up on either Bundy or Harvey. Both top 5 prospects in an organization short on pitching.
kingjenrry
Hunter Harvey pitched zero professional innings in 2015 due to an injured elbow. He has also never pitched in the high minors. Bundy missed nearly all of 2014 and 2015 due to elbow injuries. Blackmon is an good but not great Major League baseball player. Keep some perspective. Sure, Harvey and Bundy are easily Top 5 prospects in that organization but it’s really unrealistic to expect either to contribute significantly for the Major League team in 2016.
Mark 20
I really want to see the jays make a push for gallardo. would add some much needed stability to our question mark of a rotation.
cmb1974
I think the east will be and out war this year
greatd
I wonder if the Nats and White Sox who lost out on Cespedes will allocate their money else where in the likes of Fister and Gallardo.
jodendahl
Makes Zero sense for the Rockies unless they also sign Latos or Fister and trade an OF for another SP. Rockies have 2 – 3 #5’s on their roster and some average – good AAA pitchers on their roster.
Gallarado alone adds a couple wins but last place in NL west is a lot closer than a WS contender.
Colors field and Lodo is a great place to spend a summers evening abusing your liver while some people play baseball.
Ray Ray
So sign no one unless it makes you a WS contender? Signing Mike Trout wouldn’t make the Rockies WS contenders. However, signing a veteran SP like Gallardo might add only 2 wins or so this year (I think more actual wins, but we’ll go with your number). But it will add a nice veteran to take over as staff ace for de la Rosa. Everyone wants to do a nuclear rebuild, but you can’t just trade away all veterans and expect rookies to learn to win. The Cubs didn’t do much until Jon Lester, Miguel Montero, and Dexter Fowler came along to help the young guys. Even the Astros needed a Jed Lowrie and an Evan Gattis to teach their talented young guys how to win at the big league level.
Do I think a Gallardo signing makes the Rox contenders? No, probably not. Do I think a Gallardo signing makes the Rox a better team? Yes I do.. Will it make the Rockies a better team in the future? Yes, 100% wholeheartedly without a doubt.
jodendahl
I hear what your saying. The Rockies have proven they can not develope or draft successfully pitching again and again.
This is the reason why I believe they need to go after pitching not a pitcher.
jodendahl
A step in the right direction absolutely, but they still have miles to go.
Ray Ray
Yeah I mean I would love to go out and sign the Mets starting five, but unfortunately they are not available. I would much rather get a pitcher than pitching. They have tried the getting quantity over quality before and that’s how we ended up with Kyle Kendrick and Jeremy Guthrie. I’d rather go for a potential staff ace.
Dock_Elvis
That’s not entirely fair. It neglects the massive front office and amatuer scouting overhaul the Rockies have undergone. They’ve grown their own pitching, and when they have its resulted in success..Ubaldo Jimenez and Jeff Francis come to mind and that WS team. They do have an offensive advantage with Coors…holding down ANY opposing offense at Coors is a major deal.
kingjenrry
On the flipside, with the Dodgers and Giants where they are, the Rockies’ best strategy is probably a Cubs/Astros/Phillies-style rebuild. They could pick up reclamation projects like Fister or Latos on a cheap deal and hope they can flip them at the deadline for prospects but it really doesn’t make sense for them to lose a draft pick for a #3/4 starter like Gallardo. They need warm bodies, not older guys with only a little bit of upside who cost draft picks.
Dock_Elvis
I don’t believe they lose anything really for Gallardo. They do have a nice system coming along. The Dodgers will always be vicious giving their resources. I figured this move for a starter might come visit trade..maybe not. Denver is tricky for sure. Kind of a weird flux going on right now. I think we’ll have a better grasp after the deadline
mfm0411
Would like to see the Red Sox sign Gallardo to a 1 or 2 year deal. Need a number 2
quisenberrya
No one should be on the fister bandwagon. Lost velocity. 86 mph fastball. Theres a reason no one has signed him. Gallardo used to be a good pitcher but his expected salary and slow market have teams feeling they dont need him. Ervin santana is a good example.
baseballrat
You mean the Ervin Santana that’s gonna make 53mil over the next 4yrs?? Yea… That’s a GREAT example. Looks like good #’s to me
Dock_Elvis
It’s his draft pick attachment. Gallardo is the type that a team like the Pirates latches and ride to 15 wins. Saying he’s not gonna K 220 or be Milwaukee prime neglects the adjustments he’s made to being a fairly solid 2-3 on a contender
Niekro
Would actually be a good move Gallardo has the mindset that could work in Colorado if they could find a way to land Cobb in a trade they could have two very capable guys of handling Coors, and would be good mentors, teach the younger pitchers that you can not rely on pure stuff in Coors, instead rely on changing speeds and locating.
kingjenrry
To be fair, you can’t rely on pure stuff anywhere in the big leagues since the hitters will work you out.
coldgoldenfalstaff
I’d like to see the Astros sign him, another veteran starter would really help, considering the near-ready starter prospects they already gave up this year.
Also, it would be a welcome change to see Crane spend money on a quality player over relying on draft picks. That needs to start happening soon with their contention window opening and prospect ranks thinning.