Let’s take a look in at the AL Central, which is currently fronted by a surprising Twins club — though not due to the poor performance of the rest of the division. With the Indians streaking and the Royals and Tigers still looking like threats, to say nothing of a White Sox team that is still in the picture as well, it’s probably not too soon to call this the most competitive division in baseball.
- White Sox GM Rick Hahn says that he still expects several players to improve their play back toward their career norms, as MLB.com’s Scott Merkin reports. While Hahn rightly notes that there’s still plenty of time, of course, the AL Central does not look like the easiest division to make a run at from behind. That means that Chicago will increasingly need to consider “contingency plans,” as Merkin puts it, if buying at the deadline does not make sense. “Marching orders for our scouts heading out of Spring Training were looking at our positions of need at the big league level and targeting guys to help shore those up for a stretch run,” explains Hahn. “At the same time, we have our pro scouts out at the Minor League level preparing for, should we need to go the other way, and look at more prospect-focused deals. At this point, our intent is to look to add at the Deadline and put ourselves in a better position to win.”
- Young Tigers third baseman Nick Castellanos has always seemed primed to hit in the big leagues, though that remains a work in progress. While he has yet to turn things on at the dish, however, he has made a significant improvement in his glovework, as Grantland’s Ben Lindbergh examines. Castellanos acknowledges that “the game definitely got fast for [him] a little bit” at third after a long pause in his work at that position. It took a lot of work and subtle adjustments, but Lindbergh explains that Castellanos has made strides in completing more difficult plays, especially on balls hit down the line. Certainly, the overall improvement bodes well for his long-term ability to stick at third, though his bat will need to come around as well.
- Fellow infielder Hernan Perez is now on the move from the Tigers after being claimed by the Brewers yesterday. GM Dave Dombrwoski says that he had attempted to recoup some value from Perez in trade, but interest was minimal. While that gave some hope that he’d get through waivers, it didn’t prove to be the case. (Video link via MLive.com.)
tune-in for baseball
DD could have packaged Perez plus a good prospect to get Gose from Toronto. They needed an infielder and wanted to get rid of Gose. The extra prospect to sweeten the deal would have allowed us to keep Travis. Don;t know why the Tiger organization was so high on Perez and willing to give up on Travis instead.
theo in 2016
They wanted someone capable of starting. Not a utility guy
BoldyMinnesota
travis so far has shown hes much more than a utility man
stymeedone
I’m guessing he meant Toronto wanted someone capable of starting.
BoldyMinnesota
Oh ya I see that now
stymeedone
Travis is a 5’9″ power hitting 2B, who was average with the glove. He looked like he did not have a very high ceiling. Perez was better with the glove and was actually able to play a passable SS. Both looked like utility players, but defense usually wins out for that job. Toronto wanted Travis, not Perez. Neither was going to beat out Kinsler.
tune-in for baseball
I realize they wanted Travis but the Blue Jays really wanted to move Gose. We could have said no and sweetened a deal with Perez and they would probably have taken it. Not much difference between the two last winter.
You are probably right regarding Perez having a better glove and could play a passable SS.That even makes the trade for Gose a better deal with him,not Travis. My guess is he was insurance in case Iggy did not return. I still think Travis could have taken that role and had more options. DD really did not play that hand well at all.
stymeedone
I’m happy at how it worked out. I don’t think Perez was looked at as a starter by Toronto. I think Detroit also looked at him as no more than a utility player. As the article stated, DD tried to trade Perez but couldn’t get an offer. After a quick start, both Gose and Travis have slowed down. Both teams got what they were looking for, just not sure how good each player will end up being.
Doug
I love that the AL Central is “the most competitive division in baseball,” while the AL East is a just a disaster when explained by baseball media, while there are two teams worse than any AL East team in every other division in MLB.
theo in 2016
There is just no real good team in the AL East. Lots of flaws. But the talent is still there
stl_cards16
There is also at least 2 teams in every other division with as good or better record than every team in the AL East.
stl_cards16
And what you said is not true. There are only 5 teams in all of baseball with a worse record than the Red Sox, not sure how that could be 2 in every division. Also only two 4th place teams have a worse record than the 4th place team in the AL East (Jays). Basically, someone has to win when they play each other.
Doug
Someone also has to LOSE when they play each other 19 times each, thus the parity. The AL East doesn’t have two “patsies” in the division like those that get to play Miami-Philly, Milwaukee-Cincy, Arizona-Colorado, Seattle-Oakland, Chicago-Cleveland (all of whom the Red Sox are a better team than, regardless of their record).
theo in 2016
Oakland is probably better.
stl_cards16
No team in the AL East has to play 19 games against a good team. If these rosters were on teams in the AL West it would be the laughing stock of baseball. The only thing the AL East has going for it is the team names.
Doug
Actually, I think they’d be 1-5 with the rest of the West teams 6-10. The Angels might edge the Rays for 5th by year’s end.
Tigers fan for life
Chicago is better than Boston and Cleveland is better than half the AL East Kluber and the Indians got off to a slow start but are starting to heat up.
Dock_Elvis
Whenever I hear disaster referring to the East I automatically think that writers are just perplexed at a world where neither the Yankees or Red Sox are 20 games over .500
Vandals Took The Handles
The ALC is the best division in MLB, as well as the most competitive. All 5 teams are good, some are very good. In May their W-L percentage was the highest it has ever been for a one month period since the division was established. They played a lot of teams from the ALE, ALW amd NLC in May.
Doug
And they are 14-16 vs. the AL East (so far, I expect a bigger disparity by year’s end)
MarvinBerry
Wait a minute… “All 5 teams are good.”
That includes the Indians. Amazing. I challenge you to admit that on the other site you visit. You know, the site where you tell all the Indians fans how dumb they are for liking the team…
Doug
Hey, did anyone notice which division has the best record in MLB now? Hint…it doesn’t have a “Central” or “West” (or the Phillies) in it!
Dock_Elvis
AL Central is certainly competitive, but the West will likely end up being pretty stiff as well. Odds are that Houston tumbles a bit and everyone but Oakland appears to be able to make some kind of run.
stymeedone
Everyone seems to think that Houston is a fluke. Look at the batting numbers and tell me which players on Houston are having a career year? I don’t see any. In fact, most are hitting below their norm and are likely to improve. If they add at the deadline, I wouldn’t be surprised to see them hold their lead all season.
Vandals Took The Handles
Other then the Angels, there isn’t another solid team in the ALW.
One thing I’ve noticed with the emergence of the Astros, Cubs and Twins this year – all with a new manager and a lot of young players called up from the minors this year and last – is this….
People misread the Royals last year, thinking they just got hot and lucky. Many teams FO’s and owners felt – “if we just get into the playoffs, then anything can happen”. So they went out during the off-season and built a bunch of rotisserie league teams that looked good on paper. Unfortunately those teams don’t play on paper, they play on a field against opposing teams. I mentioned to a friend this morning that MLB is very hard to watch this year. So many teams depend on getting good pitching and/or good hitting that day to win. The teams are disjointed – their players don’t seem to know how to play with one another. My friend says the big contracts got too many players fat and lazy.
MarvinBerry
I’m glad you let us know what you said to your friend as well as what he said back to you.
Yesterday, I said to a friend “holy crap! What a debut by Joey Gallo!” My friend said “yes, yes indeed. It was an excellent debut.”
You say “MLB is very hard to watch this year. So many teams depend on getting good pitching and/or good hitting that day to win.”
Huh? That is a description of the game of baseball. I don’t get what is so hard for you to watch.
M.Kit
The Rangers (0.5 game back of the Angels) would like to have a word with you
Dock_Elvis
I’m not sure they sustain…some of their team stats are very high. But they’ve made it a race for sure. I’m not discounting them, they can do it….but they can also be Pittsburgh of a few seasons ago. Also take a look at their strength of schedule…it was weaker in April an May.
willi
If they get Cole Hamels !
DontPush
I feel bad for Rick Hahn. He did everything right this off-season and this disaster of a team has been the result. Don’t know where exactly the problem is but it is clear that there is a problem.
stymeedone
I see some regression from their rookies (sophomore jinx). Poor seasons from players switching leagues. I might look at a new batting coach. Other than that, their needs still seem to be the same as last year, catcher, third base, second base, and back of the rotation and middle relief. This team had too far to climb to do it all in one season. I still like what Hahn did. Its just not a finished product.
sascoach2003
Baseball, like most professional sports, is a league of adjustments. You HAVE to be able to make adjustments, in the field, at the plate, on the mound, or you just don’t have a long sustainable career…
DontPush
True, but you’re still getting bottomed out numbers from all of your big ticket acquisitions. It’s easy to throw the manager under the bus but this team is not cohesive and it shows.
theo in 2016
He didnt do anything right. Alexei and gillespie astl starters is just not a playoff team. I liked alexei but the powers gone and without ghat hes a bad hitter. Eaton melky and quintana are prolly the only ones underperforming. Shark too but he was slightly over rated
DontPush
Alexei is a career .275 hitter and he’s on pace for 20 HR which is about what he does every year. Not to mention he was an All Star and the Silver Slugger last season. He is not the issue. The guys that you mentioned are the issue
theo in 2016
His defense has gotten worse and hes on pace for 7 homers this year. And average doesnt matter when you dont walk.
DontPush
He has never walked and has always hit for more power in the hotter months of the season (exception:last year). He’ll get his 12-16 HR. As far as defense, more of the same. He’s an average MLB SS. But again, he is not the issue. Hahn took on $50 mil+ per year this year in FA/Samardijza. And, at the time, they all looked like the right moves. To get 2014 production out of the 2015 White Sox is unacceptable. There’s poison in the well.
theo in 2016
Alexei is a huge problem, he used to be a plus plus defender, he might hit 10 homers but under 300 obp. Laroche is exactly what you would expect. Melky was a bad signing ( low power/low obp not a great fielder). Shark hasnt been great but i was never high on him. Biggest problems are the danks extension, counting on gillespie as an everyday 3b and the melky contract going forward. They literally need a whole new infield save laroche.
sascoach2003
Nick Castellanos has become the Tigers 2000s version of Aurellio Rodriguez…
JimBaily
Wasn’t he “coach” on Cheers?
willi
Castellanos was overrated as hitter and was always a mediocre fielder.