The Cardinals announced that they have recalled right-hander Riley O’Brien from Triple-A Memphis. Fellow righty Shawn Armstrong has been designated for assignment as the corresponding move. John Denton of MLB.com relayed the news on X prior to the official announcement.
Armstrong, 33, was just acquired prior to the trade deadline, with the Cards sending former top prospect Dylan Carlson the other way. Since switching jerseys, Armstrong’s results have actually been good. He has tossed 12 2/3 innings over 11 outings, allowing 2.84 earned runs per nine innings. He struck out 24.5% of batters faced and only gave out walks at a 4.1% clip.
Despite the good overall results, Armstrong may be a victim of circumstances. The club used four relievers on Sunday and four last night, with Armstrong being one of the four in both games. Perhaps he was going to be unavailable tonight, so the club has nudged him out of the way as they get a fresh arm into the mix of a fairly taxed relief group. Armstrong can’t be optioned as a player with more than five years of service time, so he’s been pushed off the 40-man roster.
Beyond that, it’s also possible that the club is hoping for a little bit of cost savings here for the final month of the season. Armstrong isn’t making a ton of money, as his $2.05MM salary is relatively light in MLB terms. But since he has been pitching well, it’s possible some club may be interested in claiming him off waivers, which would take the contract off the Cardinals’ hands. If he is claimed prior to September, he would be playoff eligible with his new club. That means his odds of getting claimed should be higher now than they will be in a few days’ time.
Perhaps it’s too strong to characterize this move as a waving of the white flag, but it does perhaps illustrate where the season is at for St. Louis. They are currently 65-66 and six games out of a playoff spot. They could make a late charge in September but would have to bypass at least four clubs in the standings while also fending off the clubs that are just behind them. The Playoff Odds at FanGraphs give the Cards just a 1.9% chance of sneaking in while the PECOTA Standings are only slightly more optimistic at 3%.
They could certainly play well down the stretch without Armstrong but they just made a notable sacrifice to get this guy less than a month ago. Carlson was a former first-round pick and spent many years as a prospect who figured to be a big part of the club’s future. The club gave up two and a half years of Carlson for a few months of Armstrong, but is now likely losing Armstrong after just 11 appearances, seemingly hoping to just put some extra money into the pockets of ownership.
For with better playoff odds, it seems likely one of them will claim Armstrong. For the 2022-24 seasons, he has pitched 173 innings with a 3.64 ERA, 24.6% strikeout rate and 6.6% walk rate. That includes 11 holds and three saves. There aren’t many ways to upgrade a roster now that the trade deadline has passed, so Armstrong is an interesting candidate given his good numbers and modest salary. He’s scheduled to hit free agency at the end of this season.