The Brewers announced a series of roster moves earlier today as they optioned infielders Caleb Durbin and Tyler Black to minor league camp and released outfielder Manuel Margot. In addition, Curt Hogg of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel writes that non-roster invitee Jake Bauers has an upward mobility clause in his contract and that the Brewers are “close” to a decision on whether to roster him themselves or offer teams around the league the opportunity to do so.
The decision to option both Durbin and Black to the minors is a surprising one, as both had been in the conversation for playing time at third base. Durbin came to the Brewers this winter alongside Nestor Cortes as part of the Devin Williams trade, while Black was the club’s first-round pick back in 2021 and made his big league debut last year. With both Durbin and Black now ticketed for Triple-A to open the season, it appears duties at the hot corner will fall to a platoon of Vinny Capra and Oliver Dunn, with Dunn getting the lion’s share of playing time.
While Black has just 49 plate appearances at the MLB level and Durbin has yet to make his big league debut, neither of the club’s alternatives at the hot corner have substantial big league experience either. Dunn appeared in 41 games for the Brewers in his rookie year last season, slashing a lackluster .221/.282/.316 in 104 trips to the plate. Capra, meanwhile, has bounced between the Blue Jays, Pirates, and Brewers while appearing in each of the last three MLB seasons but has just 20 games and 37 plate appearances total at the big league level under his belt, with a career .156/.250/.219 slash line in that time.
Turning to Margot, the 30-year-old experienced the worst season of his career with the Twins last year as he hit just .238/.289/.337 while splitting time primarily between the outfield corners. That lackluster production led him to sign a minor league deal with the Brewers last month, though it appears his .250/.314/.375 slash line in 35 trips to the plate this spring wasn’t enough to convince Milwaukee to carry him on the roster entering the year, even after the loss of Blake Perkins to the injured list. With Margot no longer in the fold, the job of fifth outfielder behind Jackson Chourio, Christian Yelich, Garrett Mitchell, and Sal Frelick appears likely to fall to infielder/outfielder Isaac Collins. Collins, 27, made his big league debut with the Brewers last year and hit just .118/.211/.118 in 11 games with the club. He posted strong numbers at the Triple-A level, however, and has flashed the versatility in the minors to not only play both outfield corners but also handle both second and even third base. That versatility should allow Collins to offer depth to the Brewers both in the outfield and at the hot corner as the season begins.
As for Bauers, it seems likely that the Brewers will keep the first baseman in the fold given that, as noted by Hogg, the club now has just 13 healthy position players in camp after optioning Durbin and Black to the minor leagues today. It’s at least plausible that the club could make an external addition, but said addition could just as easily bump a player like Collins or Capra off the roster. If Bauers does break camp with the Brewers, he’ll do so on the heels of a 2024 season where he appeared in 116 games for Milwaukee, though he struggled to a lackluster .199/.301/.361 slash line in 346 trips to the plate as he did so. Despite those pedestrian numbers, Bauers still offers the Brewers a lefty bat off the bench and a complement to the right-handed hitting Rhys Hoskins at first base, which could be particularly useful if Hoskins doesn’t bounce back from his own down 2024 campaign this year.