The Tigers are next in our Offseason In Review series.
Major League Signings
- Victor Martinez, DH/C: four years, $50MM.
- Joaquin Benoit, RP: three years, $16.5MM.
- Brandon Inge, 3B: two years, $11.5MM. Includes $6MM club option for 2013 with a $500K buyout.
- Jhonny Peralta, SS: two years, $11.25MM. Includes $6MM club option for 2013 with a $500K buyout.
- Magglio Ordonez, RF: one year, $10MM.
- Brad Penny, SP: one year, $3MM.
- Total spend: $102.25MM.
Notable Minor League Signings
Extensions
- Ryan Raburn, LF: two years, $3.4MM.
Trades and Claims
- Acquired RP Pedro Perez from Red Sox for IF Brent Dlugach
- Acquired SP Kevin Eichhorn and RP Ryan Robowski from Diamondbacks for SP Armando Galarraga
Notable Losses
Summary
The Tigers' offseason was all about being aggressive early, as they locked up Inge, Peralta, Benoit, and Martinez before the end of November. GM Dave Dombrowski was able to land his top targets, but often had to overpay in the process.
Dombrowski's commitment to Benoit shook the relief market. The contrast was stark for a reliever whose previous contract was a minor league deal. Explained the GM, "When you want to get the best players at certain positions, you have to be aggressive and prepared to do things." The Tigers should be commended for signing the reliever they felt was the best available, going the extra mile to get it done. Like most eight-figure relief contracts, this one is risky – Benoit is a 33-year-old who had rotator cuff surgery in January of '09.
The early push to sign Inge and Peralta is more difficult to understand. Despite being known as an offensive-minded infielder, Peralta hasn't hit much since '08. And while Inge might make up for Peralta's lack of range, he's a negative with the bat as well. The free agent market typically doesn't reward defense-first players with the kind of contract Inge received. The Tigers' goal here seemed to be to secure the left side of their infield and have cost certainty before moving on to bigger fish.
That big fish was Martinez (pictured). The popularity of Martinez and Adam Dunn on the free agent market showed that teams are willing to make large commitments to players with little defensive value. Martinez has more than Dunn, in that the former can don the tools of ignorance without embarrassing himself. I would have liked the V-Mart signing more if it didn't require giving the Red Sox the best unprotected draft pick at #19. Now, the Tigers won't have a pick in the 2011 draft until #76. Still, the team got the capable middle of the order bat they sought from the outset of the offseason.
Dombrowski was able to further bolster the offense by signing Ordonez, who chose the popular Scott Boras "pillow contract" as he attempts to rebuild value after a fractured ankle ended his season in July. Unlike Carlos Pena, Ordonez was at least coming off a strong season. However, at age 37, Ordonez's durability will be a huge question mark – especially with Martinez claiming the DH spot most of the time.
Converted reliever Phil Coke filled one rotation spot, while Dombrowski took a $3MM flier on Penny for the other. Sooner or later teams will stop guaranteeing Penny millions of dollars on the hope that he will have another 2007. To be fair, Penny only needs to provide 100 solid innings to be worth the $3MM guarantee. The bigger question is where the Tigers will turn when they inevitably need a sixth or seventh starter. Andy Oliver is big league ready, though top prospect Jacob Turner is only 19 years old. Lefties Casey Crosby, Duane Below, Charlie Furbush, and Adam Wilk could factor in depending on the magnitude of the Tigers' need. MLBTR's Ben Nicholson-Smith addressed the Tigers' rotation depth last month in a piece at FanGraphs.
The Tigers had significant money come off the books after the '10 season, and despite their numerous free agent commitments the Opening Day payroll still appears to be down about $27MM. I wasn't a fan of all of Dombrowski's choices, but I respect his aggressive pursuit of primary targets. If the 2011 Tigers fail, it won't be because the market got away from them and they had to go to Plan B or C.
Photo courtesy of Icon SMI.
“The popularity of Martinez and Adam Dunn on the free agent market showed that teams are willing to make large commitments to players with little defensive value”
I don’t completely agree with this statement. IIRC, there were a glut of DH-types available as free agents (also including Manny and Vlad Guerrero) or for trade (Ryan Doumit) last offseason, and only a handful of them (Dunn, Martinez) got “large” commitments.
But Manny and Vlad had no defensive value rather than little, while Doumit has little value on either end.
Are you suggesting that Dunn had any defensive value?
He does! It’s just negative value.
I guess there is a small distinction, I’ll give you that. :shrug:
Of course, Penny will not provide 100 solid innings, and that’s because he’s complete crap. He has nothing left.
Nice work locking up Peralta and Inge though. The team would never get their 81 wins without those guys!
did you see what penny did against the rangers today ?? penny is not crap he just needed to work on getting the ball down in the zone. and penny worked that out with rick knapp ( tigers pitching coach) on friday.
Yes, I saw the game. How many lineouts to the warning track do you need to induce in order to win every day? Does he have something worked out with Raburn, like an alley-oop play, where he throws a meatball right down the middle and Raburn pulls it back over the fence, preventing the homer and obtaining the valuable out?
There was nothing on most of those pitches. Nothing. If you think Penny is going to win a lot of games like the one yesterday, you’re nuts. He’s garbage.
Yeah…Penny will provide 100 innings, good or bad, they will be 100 innings.
And if you can think of someone outside of Adrian beltre who was better than Inge at third, please let me know.
Okay, Ryan Zimmerman is better. Scott Rolen, old as he is, is probably a little better. Kouzmanoff, Headley and a bunch of other third basemen put up better UZRs last year (Inge was 11th, just behind Alberto Callaspo and just ahead of Mark Reynolds). UZR shouldn’t be our only measure, however. The Fielding Bible gave Longoria the award last year, with Zimmerman 2nd, Beltre 3rd, and Headley 4th. I don’t even know where Inge finished.
We Tigers fans need to let go of this. Inge might have been the nest a few years ago (outside of Beltre), but he isn’t anymore. He’s fun to watch though. He’s a good defender, and though he hit a nice walk-off shot this afternoon, he’s just not much of a hitter. He isn’t worth the money he’s been given.
I hated the Penny signing, even though it’s only a one year deal, since he had some brutal AL East numbers a few years ago, and he’s injury prone. I wish some of the kids would have gotten a chance this year. Adam Wilk should have made the team (instead of Brad Thomas and his awful peripherals), and I’m surprised that Oliver isn’t getting another long look.
Oliver will get a chance soon enough, once someone gets hurt or one of our other guys, probably Penny, craps the bed.
I still don’t get why DD didn’t pull the trigger on a trade for Michael Young, after the Rangers said they would eat half his contract. Rather have him in there somewhere at Short or Second than what we have now.